Home
About Tom
Ask the Therapist
Paperwork
Directions
Site Map

 

 

Is this grief or depression?

A.

Hosting Grief vs. Depression is Like Hosting a Kitten vs. a Tiger  

A psychiatrist friend of mine sometimes says “just because a dog has fleas doesn’t mean it can’t also have ticks.”  Meaning, you can have grief and depression.  Double trouble. 

First of all there are important differences between losing a parent and losing a marriage.

The former is expected, and generally in keeping with the course of your life. It's usually less disruptive. The loss of a marriage means the loss of an entire vision of your future and a re-working of the structure of your life, which is put into upheaval. It’s enough to make anyone feel they lost the air in their lungs.

Back to the two types of sadness.  The difference between grief and depression is hard for me to understand, much less describe. How can we possibly draw a clear line between the two? But if I think about it very generally, stifling grief will tend to cause some trouble. Crying about a loss is natural, expected, wholesome. Entertaining the idea that it's problematic just adds tension which compounds the matter. If grief was an animal, it would grow quiet and satisfied as you feed it.

 Depression on the other hand would be a level of sadness and distress that is somehow out of proportion to your events and circumstances. It will thrive on distorted thinking (see Depressed Thinking) and depressive behavior (withdrawing, neglecting tasks, agitated or sluggish movement, changing diet and sleep patterns, and so on). In this case, prolonged crying, especially I think the gasping, spasmodic kind of crying, might not feel like a good release; more exhausting and out of control. If there is such a thing as a good cry, it could have a counterpart evil twin, the bad cry. If depression was an animal, feeding it would cause it to grow big, aggressive and hungry. I have to stress that I'm being general and speculative here. Readers should decide if parts of this are true or not in their own case.

Return to Previous Page

 

 

Q.

Do you have a Question?

  

 

 

Question

I have just completed my divorce. I was depressed leading up to this, and while I thought I would experience relief, I feel worse. It’s like I’ve been knocked down, gasping hardly able to cry. My friend told me I’m grieving. But I grieved when I lost my parents and it was nothing like this.


Disclaimer:  I am not acting as a your clinical provider in these discussions, and there is nothing here that can substitute for personal care from a qualified professional.  Please utilize this material for general ideas only, not as personal advice.